Skip to main content
Skip to footer content
Family of Brands
Legal Sea Foods
Michel Design Works
Montebello
Napa Valley Naturals
Stonewall Home
Stonewall Kitchen
Tillen Farms
Urban Accents
Vermont Coffee Company
Vermont Village
Village Candle
Meet The Whole Family
More Ways to Buy
Store Locator
Company Stores
SWK Subscriptions
Guest Services
FAQ
Shipping & Tax
Contact Us
Find Us on Social
Instagram
Facebook
Pinterest
YouTube
TikTok
The Pantry Blog
Sign in
Cart
Back
Close
×
Our Family of Brands
Legal Sea Foods
Michel Design Works
Montebello
Napa Valley Naturals
Stonewall Home
Stonewall Kitchen
Tillen Farms
Urban Accents
Vermont Coffee Company
Vermont Village
Village Candle
Specialty Food
All Food
Company Classics
Stock Up and Save
What's New
Baking & Breakfast Mixes
Beverages
Condiments
Dessert Sauces & Toppings
Dips & Spreads
Dressings
Jams, Jellies & Marmalades
Oils & Vinegars
Pasta, Risottos & Soups
Pickled Vegetables
Sauces
Snacks & Sweets
Spices & Seasonings
Syrups, Maple & Honey
Gifts
All Gifts
All Gift Baskets
Best Selling Gifts
Gifts For Every Occasion
Holiday Packaging
Breakfast Gifts
Cocktail & Bar Gifts
Desserts & Baking Gifts
Dinner Gifts
Food Gifts
Gift Cards
Gifts Over $100
Gifts $50 to $100
Gifts Under $50
Gluten Free Gifts
Grilling Gifts
Home Fragrance Gifts
Hostess Gifts
Jammin' Gifts
Product Collections
Signature Packaging
Snacking Gifts
Home
Bags, Totes & Sea Bags®
Baking & Cookware
Baskets, Bins, Boxes & Books
Home Fragrance
Home Goods
Home Keeping
Kitchen Appliances
Kitchen Linens
Kitchen Tools
Tabletop & Bar
Personal Care
All Personal Care
Self Care Gifts
Foaming Hand Soaps
Hand Care Caddies & Napkin Sets
Bar Soaps & Soap Dishes
Body Butters & Scrubs
Bubble Bath & Body Wash
Hand Creams & Lotions
Liquid Hand Soaps
Seasonal
What's New
Best of the Family of Brands
Shelf Stable Produce
Spring Celebrations
Mother's Day Gifts
Tea Time
Scents of the Season
Game-Day MVPs
Charcuterie
Party Favorites
Italian Dinner
New England Favorites
Sweet Maple Favorites
Taco Night
Coffee Shop
Brunch
Recipes
Browse By Brand
Latest Recipes
Recipe Videos
Company Classics
Appetizers
Bagel Toppers
Beverages
Breads
Breakfast
Desserts
Dessert Waffles
Grilled Cheese
Main Courses
Salads
Side Dishes
Soups
Toast Toppers
Barn Sale
All Barn Sale
Sale Food
Sale Gifts
Sale Kitchen & Home
Sign in
Our Family of Brands
Legal Sea Foods
Michel Design Works
Bath & Body
Home
Shop By Collection
Gift Ideas
Spring & Summer 2024
What's New
Montebello
What's New
Napa Valley Naturals
What's New
Stonewall Home
What's New
Stonewall Home Room Sprays & Reed Diffusers
Stonewall Home Candles
Stonewall Home Hand Soaps
Shop All Stonewall Home
Stonewall Kitchen
Tillen Farms
Shop All Tillen Farms
Bloody Mary Brunches
Urban Accents
Recipe Mix Solutions
Spices
Gift Ideas for Foodies
Gourmet Popcorn & Seasonings
Pizza Essentials
Vermont Coffee Company
Flavored Coffee
Ground Coffee
Whole Bean Coffee
Vermont Village
Vermont Village Apple Cider Vinegar
Village Candle
Browse All Deals
Browse All Village Candles
Shop By Collection
Shop By Color
Shop By Fragrance
Shop By Season
Sweet Scents
Specialty Food
All Food
Company Classics
Stock Up and Save
What's New
Baking & Breakfast Mixes
Baking Mixes
Breakfast Mixes
Dessert Mixes
Beverages
Cocktail Garnishes
Cocktail Mixers, Syrups & Shrubs
Coffee (Ground & Whole Bean)
Tea & Hot Chocolate
Condiments
Aiolis & Tartar Sauce
Chutneys
Ketchup, Mustards & Relish
Dessert Sauces & Toppings
Cocktail Cherries
Dessert Sauces
Dips & Spreads
Dipping Sauces & Mixes
Fruit & Nut Butters
Salsas & Quesos
Spreads
Dressings
Jams, Jellies & Marmalades
Oils & Vinegars
Culinary Oils
Dipping Oils
Vinegars
Pasta, Risottos & Soups
Pasta
Risottos & Soups
Pickled Vegetables
Sauces
Grille Sauces & Marinades
Pesto, Pasta & Pizza Sauces
Seafood Sauces
Starter & Simmering Sauces
Taco Sauces
Snacks & Sweets
Applesauce
Candy & Cookies
Crackers, Chips & Pretzels
Popcorn & Seasonings
Snack Mixes & Nuts
Spices & Seasonings
Bottled Spices
Plant Based Meatless Meal Starters
Meat & Fish Seasonings
Pizza Seasonings
Veggie Seasonings
Syrups, Maple & Honey
Gifts
All Gifts
All Gift Baskets
Best Selling Gifts
Gifts For Every Occasion
Housewarming Gifts
Family Gifts
Wedding & Engagement Gifts
Gifts for Her
Gifts for Him
Gifts for the Office
Holiday Packaging
Breakfast Gifts
Cocktail & Bar Gifts
Desserts & Baking Gifts
Dinner Gifts
Food Gifts
Gift Cards
Gifts Over $100
Gifts $50 to $100
Gifts Under $50
Gluten Free Gifts
Grilling Gifts
Home Fragrance Gifts
Hostess Gifts
Jammin' Gifts
Product Collections
Signature Packaging
Snacking Gifts
Home
Bags, Totes & Sea Bags®
Baking & Cookware
Baskets, Bins, Boxes & Books
Home Fragrance
Candles
Candle Accessories
Diffusers
Odor Neutralizers
Room Sprays
Home Goods
Home Keeping
Home Keeping Tools
Fine Home Keeping
Kitchen Appliances
Kitchen Linens
Tea & Dish Towels
Aprons
Oven Mitts & Pot Holders
Kitchen Tools
Cutting & Chopping
Gadgets
Utensils
Tabletop & Bar
Accessories
Bar & Glassware
Dinnerware
Flatware
Napkins & Placemats
Serveware
Personal Care
All Personal Care
Self Care Gifts
Foaming Hand Soaps
Hand Care Caddies & Napkin Sets
Bar Soaps & Soap Dishes
Body Butters & Scrubs
Bubble Bath & Body Wash
Hand Creams & Lotions
Liquid Hand Soaps
Seasonal
What's New
Best of the Family of Brands
Shelf Stable Produce
Spring Celebrations
Mother's Day Gifts
Tea Time
Scents of the Season
Game-Day MVPs
Charcuterie
Party Favorites
Italian Dinner
New England Favorites
Sweet Maple Favorites
Taco Night
Coffee Shop
Brunch
Recipes
Browse By Brand
Recipes with Stonewall Kitchen Products
Recipes with Urban Accents Products
Recipes with Tillen Farms products
Recipes with Montebello Products
Recipes with Napa Valley Naturals Products
Recipes with Vermont Village Products
Latest Recipes
Recipe Videos
Company Classics
Appetizers
Bagel Toppers
Beverages
Breads
Breakfast
Desserts
Dessert Waffles
Grilled Cheese
Main Courses
Salads
Side Dishes
Soups
Toast Toppers
Barn Sale
All Barn Sale
Sale Food
Sale Gifts
Sale Kitchen & Home
Sign in
FREE SHIPPING OVER $99
|
USE CODE FS99
[ONLINE ONLY]
Home
Recipes
Grilled Cheese
7 Results
Sort By
Most Popular
New Products
Price (high to low)
Price (low to high)
Filter
7 Results
Close
Reset
Product Type
Aioli
Refine by Product Type: Aioli
Chutney
Refine by Product Type: Chutney
Jam
Refine by Product Type: Jam
Mayo
Refine by Product Type: Mayo
Mustard
Refine by Product Type: Mustard
Recipe
Refine by Product Type: Recipe
Brand
Stonewall Kitchen
Refine by Brand: Stonewall Kitchen
Various
Refine by Brand: Various
Subscription Eligible
Yes
Refine by Subscription Eligible: Yes
No
Refine by Subscription Eligible: No
Product Category
Browse By Brand
Latest Recipes
Recipe Videos
Company Classics
Appetizers
Bagel Toppers
Beverages
Breads
Breakfast
Desserts
Dessert Waffles
Grilled Cheese
Main Courses
Salads
Side Dishes
Soups
Toast Toppers
Grilled Pastrami & Cheese Sandwich
Bourbon Bacon Grilled Cheese
Raspberry Brie Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Savory Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Turkey Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Caprese Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Garlicky Grilled Cheese with Tomato
